SC Decisions

MADAG BUISAN, et al., namely: HADJI MUSA MANALAG, HADJI SUKOR MAMADRA, H. SALAM TUMAGANTANG, SUGRA SUKOR BUISAN, MONAURA TUMAGANTAING, NOJA TUMAGANTANG, SULTAN BUISAN, PAULO TUMAGANTANG, DAKUNDAY MANALAG, KINGI BUISAN, UGOYPANANGBUAN,TUMBA TUMAGANTANG, MAMALO ELI, MALIGA ATOGAN, PAGUIAL SALDINA, EBRAHIM TAGURAK, HADJI ESMAEL KASAN, OTAP GANDAWALI, TWAN IT SALAM, EDEL SABAL, GUIMA H. SALAM, KATUNTONG H. SALAM, THONY IBAD, BANGKALING BANTAS, ALON KIKI, DAMDAEN TUMAGANTANG, MAMASALIDO KIKI, ROSTAN TUMAGANTANG, MONTASER DAMDAMEN, MODSOL TANDIAN, RAHMAN SUKOR, SUKARNO H. SUKOR, KUNGAS PAYAG, JIMIE BUISAN, MADAODAO KEDTUNGEN, TUTIN MANALAG, DATU ALI MANALAG, TUGAYA MANALAG, SAGANDINGAN MANALAG, SAUIATRA MANALAG, KAUTIN MANALAG, PANTASDALANDAS,ULAD BANTAS, PALANO BUISAN, PANIANG BUISAN, INDASIA BUISAN, MAKAKW A BUISAN, SULTAN BUISAN, MANTIKAN BUISAN, ABULKARIM TUMAGANTANG, SAKMAG MANALAG, DEMALANES BUISAN, MANALAG PAKAMAMA, MALAMBONG PANDIAN, ABDULKARIM TUMAGANTANG, GUIANDAL OPAO, KUSIN PUWI, H. SULAIMAN UNAK, PABLO ALQUESAR, SAGIBA GABAO, TABUAN LUAY, POTENCIANO NAVARRO, KUSIN PENEL, MALAMON TALIB, MALIGA BIDA, MOKAMAD KUDALIS, CEDULA PAGABANGAN, SALILAGUIA LENANDANG, ENGKEL ALILAYA, MANGATOG SUDANG, MANAGKING MANGATONG, SEVERINO FERNANDEZ, JOSEASGOTOKANO, MALYOD LA WADI, MANSALGAN UDAY, SANDATO DALANDAS, BANTAS DALANDAS, MAMANTAL DALANDAS, MAKALIPUAS, MAKALILAY, BINGKONG BUISAN, FARIDA SUMAGKA, NUNET YUSOP, KADIGIA SABAL, NANANGGA TAYA, MAMA BANGKALING, CORRY DAMO, BUKA LATIP, MADAODAO KADTUNGAN, KOMINIE ADAM, BANGKALING BANTAS, RONIE EDZAKAL, KEDOPAO BUTO, SARIP EDZEMBAGA, TUTEN MANALAG, ABAS LATIP, MAKALIPUAS MAKALILAY, DAGENDENGAN ZUMBAGA, PAGUIAL LUBALANG, JIMMY BUISAN, KADIL SUKOR, JAKIRI LOZANO, MANUEL MAKATIMBEL, AISA BANSUAN, TATO BUISAN, HARON ABO, MAMAAN LAMADA, THING GUIAMILON, TATO SUMAGKA, NORALYN KAHAR, MOKAGI ANTAS, KINGI BUISAN, ZAINUDEN PANAYAMAN, PIAGA MANALAG, SAGIATRA MANALAG, SAILA LATIP, PINKI KADTUNGAN, ALI ADTUNGAN, NANDING TAYA, INDA Y BUISAN, KINTOL KADTUNGAN, MALA WINIE EDZAKAL, MINGUTIN AMAL, BUGLI MANALAG, MANGAPANG SADINA, KURANUNGAN SADINA, SANGUTIN LUBALANG, DAUD H. LATIP, REY PALAMAN, MONTANER KID, BAKATED KADTUNGAN, GUIAMATULA DIMAGIL, ALON H. LATIP, SULTAN BUISAN, HADJI MUSA MANALAG, MANTO BANTAS, ABAS L. LATIP RODIEL KID, DATU BUTO ALI, ODIN TIAGO, ABDUL ANTA, EMBIT BUKA, LAGA KID, ULAMA DALUS, SUWAILA DAMDAMIN, TALILISAN PALEMBA, LANTOKAPATOG, MAKA TEGKA BANGKONG, BEMBI KUDO, MOGAWAN GINANTE, PATANG BALODTO, EUSEBIO QUIJANO, FAISAN TAYA, LAGA KAHAR, ESMAEL KID, TAYA PALAMAN, NORJANA BUISAN, TONTONGAN MANALAG, SAMIER MANGULI, SINUMAGAD BANSUAN, BHING HARON, NENENG BUISAN, DIDO KID, ZALDI AGIONG, ROWENA MANALAG, NASSER MAMALANGKAP, TANOSI ZUMBAGA, GUIDAT DANDALANAN, FATIMA KID, KIMAMA KA TIMPO, ALON GUIANDAL, MAMALUBA AKOD, AIN SUKOR and NORIA DALANDAS, all represented by BAI ANNIE C. MONTAWAL vs. COMMISSION ON AUDIT and DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS AND HIGHWAYS

OFFICE OF THE COURT ADMINISTRATOR vs. Executive Judge ILLUMINADA P. CABATO, Regional Trial Court [RTC], Baguio City; Clerk of Court IV ARMANDO G. YDIA, Process Server I SONNY S. CARAGAY, Clerk of Court III OFELIA T. MONDIGUING, Sheriff III JOSE E. ORPILLA, and Clerk III VILMA C. WAYANG, all of the Office of the Clerk of Court, Municipal Trial Court in Cities [MTCC], Baguio City; Judge ROBERTO R. MABALOT, Clerk of Court III LOURDES G. CAOLILI, and Utility Worker I ANTINO M. WAKIT, all of Branch I, MTCC, Baguio City; Judge JENNIFER P. HUMINDING, Court Stenographer II PERLA B. DELA CRUZ, Court Stenographer II MARY ROSE VIRGINIA O. MATIC, and Clerk IV LOURDES D. WANGWANG, all of Branch 2, MTCC, Baguio City; Clerk of Court REMEDIOS BALDERAS-REYES, Sheriff IV RUBEN L. ATIJERA, Cash Clerk II MERLIN ANITA N. CALICA, Process Server EDWIN V. FANGONIL, Sheriff IV ROMEO R. FLORENDO, Librarian II NAMNAMA L. LOPEZ, Clerk III JEFFREY G. MENDOZA, Clerk II ROLANDO G. MONTES, Court Stenographer III VENUS D. SAGUID, and Utility Worker I FRANCISCO D. SIAPNO, all of the Office of the Clerk of Court, RTC, Baguio City; Clerk of Court GAIL M. BACBAC-DEL ISEN, Court Stenographer III RESTITUTO A. CORPUZ, Court Stenographer MARLENE A. DOMAOANG, and Legal Researcher II FLORENCE F. SALANGO, all of Branch 3, RTC, Baguio City; Judge MIA JOY C. OALLARES-CAWED, Legal Researcher II ELIZABETH G. AUCENA, Clerk of Court V RUTH B. BAWAYAN, Court Stenographer III JOY P. CHILEM-AGUILBA, Court Stenographer III LEONILA P. FERNANDEZ, Process Server MARIA LOURDES P.A. SERENO ESPERANZA N. JACOB, Court Clerk III REYNALDO R. RAMOS, Court Interpreter III MELITA C. SALINAS, and Court Clerk III WILMA M. TAMANG, all of Branch 4, RTC, Baguio City; Judge ANTONIO M. ESTEVES, Utility Worker JONATHAN R. GERONIMO, Court Stenographer III PRECY T. GOZE, Clerk of Court V ALEJANDRO EPIFANIO D. GUERRERO, and Court Stenographer III VIRGINIA M. RAMIREZ, all of Branch 5, RTC, Baguio City; Clerk of Court MYLENE MAY ADUBE-CABUAG, Process Server ROBERTO G. COROÑA, JR., Court Stenographer III VICTORIA J. DERASMO, Clerk of Court III BOBBY D. GALANO, Utility Worker MANOLO V. MARIANO III, and Clerk III ROWENA C. PASAG, all of Branch 6, RTC, Baguio City; Judge MONA LISA TIONGSON-TABORA, Process Server ROMEO E. BARBACHANO, Court Stenographer EDNA P. CASTILLO, Court Stenographer III DOLORES M. ESERIO, Court Interpreter III GEORGE HENRY A. MANIPON, Court Stenographer III ANITA MENDOZA, Clerk III DOMINADOR B. REMIENDO, and Clerk III DOLORES G. ROMERO, all of Branch 7, RTC, Baguio City; Utility Worker GILBERT L. EVANGELISTA, Process Server EDUARDO B. RODRIGO, Court Stenographer III ELIZABETH M. LOCKEY, Court Stenographer III ANALIZA G. MADRONIO, Clerk III EV ANGELINE N. GONZALES, Court Stenographer III MARILOU M. TADAO, Court Stenographer III AGNES P. MACA-EY, Sheriff IV MARANI S. BACOLOD, Clerk III EDGARDO R. ORA TE, and Legal Researcher JESSICA D. GUANSING, all of Branch 59, RTC, Baguio City; Clerk of Court ROGER NAFIANOG, Court Stenographer III RUTH C. LAGAN, Court Stenographer III ELEANOR V. NINALGA, Clerk III ANGELINA M. SANTIAGO, Utility Worker LEO P. VALDEZ, and Clerk III SAMUEL P. VIDAD, all of Branch 60, RTC, Baguio City; Judge ANTONIO C. REYES, Court Interpreter III ELEANOR I. BUCAYCAY, Legal Researcher II JOAN G. CASTILLO, Clerk of Court V JERICO G. GAY-YA, Clerk III CONCEPCION SOLIVEN Vda. PULMANO, and Sheriff IV ALBERT G. TOLENTINO, all of Branch 61, RTC, Baguio City

SOCORRO T. CLEMENTE, as substituted by SALVADOR T. CLEMENTE vs. REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES (Department of Public Works and Highways, Region IV-A)

REPUBLIC OF THE PIDLIPPINES vs. MILLER OMANDAM UNABIA

P/INSP. II GILBERT C. SAN DIEGO vs. FACT-FINDING INVESTIGATION COMMITTEE* (Under the Office of the DEPUTY OMBUDSMAN for Military and Other Law Enforcement Officers), Represented by AGIO DON. A ESQUIVEL,

ALYANSA PARA SA BAGONG PILIPINAS, INC. (ABP), represented by Evelyn V. Jallorina and Noel Villones vs. ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, represented by its Chairman, JOSE VICENTE B. SALAZAR, DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, represented by Secretary ALFONSO G. CUSI, MERALCO, CENTRAL LUZON PREMIERE POWER CORPORATION, ST. RAPHAEL POWER GENERATION CORPORATION, PANAY ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, MARIVELES POWER GENERATION CORPORATION, GLOBAL LUZON ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, ATIMONAN ONE ENERGY, INC., REDONDO PENINSULA ENERGY, INC., and PHILIPPINE COMPETITION COMMISSION

ALYANSA PARA SA BAGONG PILIPINAS, INC. (ABP), represented by Evelyn V. Jallorina and Noel Villones vs. ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION, represented by its Chairman, JOSE VICENTE B. SALAZAR, DEPARTMENT OF ENERGY, represented by Secretary ALFONSO G. CUSI, MERALCO, CENTRAL LUZON PREMIERE POWER CORPORATION, ST. RAPHAEL POWER GENERATION CORPORATION, PANAY ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, MARIVELES POWER GENERATION CORPORATION, GLOBAL LUZON ENERGY DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION, ATIMONAN ONE ENERGY, INC., REDONDO PENINSULA ENERGY, INC., and PHILIPPINE COMPETITION COMMISSION

RENE J. HIERRO, COMPLAINANT, V. ATTY. PLARIDEL C. NAVA II, RESPONDENT.