Chartis Philippines Insurance, Inc. (formerly Philam Insurance Company, Inc.) Vs. Heung-A Shipping Corporation, et al./Heung-A Shipping Corporation, et al. Vs. Chartis Philippines Insurance, Inc. (formerly Philam Insurance Company, Inc.)
CROWN SHIPPING SERVICES/DOLPHIN SHIPMANAGEMENT INC. AND/OR CARISBROOKE SHIPPING LTD. AND/OR MR. EMMANUEL P. GOMEZ AND/OR MS. SUSAN AGUSTIN, PETITIONERS, VS. JOHN P. CERVAS, RESPONDENT
HEIRS OF JOSE MARIANO AND HELEN S. MARIANO, REPRESENTED BY DANILO DAVID S. MARIANO, MARY THERESE IRENE S. MARIANO, MA. CATALINA SOPHIA S. MARIANO, JOSE MARIO S. MARIANO, MA. LENOR S. MARIANO, MACARIO S. MARIANO AND HEIRS OF ERLINDA MARIANO VILLANUEVA, REPRESENTED IN THIS ACT BY IRENE LOURDES M. VILLANUEVA THROUGH HER ATTORNEY-IN-FACT EDITHA S. SANTUYO AND BENJAMIN B. SANTUYO, PETITIONERS, VS. CITY OF NAGA, RESPONDENT