G.R. No. 42590; March 23, 1935
Pasay Transportation Co., Inc. vs. Pampanga Bus Company and Manila Electric Company

FACTS

The Manila Electric Company (Meralco) and Pampanga Bus Company applied to the Public Service Commission for approval of a joint fare system with transfers at the intersection of Blumentritt Street and Rizal Avenue in Manila. Pasay Transportation Co., Inc., a competitor operating bus lines within Manila and its suburbs, opposed the application. The Commission approved the joint fare system, finding it would benefit the public by providing convenience and savings for passengers transferring between the lines of Meralco and Pampanga Bus. Pasay Transportation appealed the decision.

ISSUE

Did the Public Service Commission commit reversible error in approving the joint fare system between Meralco and Pampanga Bus Company?

RULING

No. The Supreme Court affirmed the decision of the Public Service Commission. The evidence showed the joint fare system would serve public convenience and result in savings for passengers, a finding supported by the record. The Commission acted within its authority in finding a public need and making the necessary order. The approval did not constitute unfair competition nor violate any deed of sale involving the parties, as Pampanga Bus was not applying for a new certificate of public convenience but only for a joint fare arrangement. The assigned errors were overruled.

AI Generated by Armztrong.